With Father’s Day just celebrated, what better time to share this story of a 1958 Corvette whose owner never forgot about it despite having to sell his beloved car nearly 60 years ago.
Now, thanks to the new YouTube show, “Lost & Found Muscle Cars,” hosted by Wes Eisenschenk, the mystery of where this Corvette has been hiding – out in the open, actually – has finally been solved.
The story begins on Feb. 19, 1963 when Virginia Buehner of Parma, Ohio bought her son Dick a gray over red 1958 Corvette using some money inherited from a relative.
Dick drove the car while he was a student at Bowling Green State University in Ohio, later telling his four children that “people don’t date Dick Buehner, they date Dick Buehner’s Corvette.”
Unfortunately, two years into his ownership, Dick’s dad made him sell the car because it had an exhaust leak and no doubt he didn’t want to risk his son’s well-being.
But while the car was gone, it definitely wasn’t erased from Dick’s memory. He frequently told his kids about his experiences with the car and always wondered where it might have ended up. Indeed, one of those sons, Brett Buehner, still has some items from the Corvette that had been saved by his dad, things like the original bill of sale showing a purchase price of $1,800, the original owner’s manual that came with the car, and the license plate that was on it in 1964.
Since Dick eventually became a teacher and supplemented his income with two other jobs, including service in the Army Reserves, he likely wouldn’t have had the necessary funds to buy back the car as the classic C1s have soared in value over the years.
Now, we get to the good part. After finding 900 “missing” cars over the years, Wes Eisenschenk set his sights on locating Dick Buehner’s Corvette.
His research would turn up some very interesting information, including the fact that it was the ’58 used in the VH-1 giveaway of every model year Corvette back in 1989, a total of 36 Corvettes that were won by a single person. Faced with the dilemma of where to store 36 Corvette, this winner decided to sell the collection as a whole to a New York artist named Peter Max.
When Wes shared that news with Brett, they were shocked to find out that Brett actually had a couple of Peter Max paintings hanging in the room right behind him!
The ’58 – along with the other 35 Corvettes in the contest – spent decades stored in warehouses, deteriorating and gathering dust, before Peter Max was convinced to sell them in 2016 to become part of yet another contest after they had been refurbished.
Wes was able to find out the most recent winner of the ’58, who ended up selling it again in April 2023 to Velma and Drew Rutherford, who were excited to find out more about their prize car from Wes and Brett. Indeed, they’ve extended an open invitation to Brett to drive the car once owned by his dad, and Brett in turn says he wants to return the owner’s manual to its rightful place once more.
Source:
Lost & Found Muscle Cars / YouTube
Related:
Indiana Man Stumbles Across His Dad’s Old Corvette For Sale and Brings It Back Home
[VIDEO] Man Buys Back His Dad’s 1965 Corvette 45 Years Later
Connecticut Man is Reunited with His Dad’s 1964 Corvette
Subscribe Now:
![[VIDEO] Lost & Found: The Hunt is Over for Dad's 1958 Corvette](https://www.corvetteblogger.com/images/content/2024/061824_6b.jpg)
![[PICS] You Can Drive Six Different Styles of Corvette, or Coquette, in Grand Theft Auto [PICS] You Can Drive Six Different Styles of Corvette, or Coquette, in Grand Theft Auto](https://www.corvetteblogger.com/images/content/uploads/2026/11/111926_7-218x150.jpg)
![[VIDEO] You Can Now Add This Event to the Corvette ZR1X List of Production Car Records [VIDEO] You Can Now Add This Event to the Corvette ZR1X List of Production Car Records](https://www.corvetteblogger.com/images/content/uploads/2026/11/111826_7-218x150.jpg)
![[VIDEO] Driving the Tremec Manual C8 Corvette on the Track [VIDEO] Driving the Tremec Manual C8 Corvette on the Track](https://www.corvetteblogger.com/images/content/uploads/2026/11/111826_4-218x150.jpg)
I don’t get it. Getting rid of your Corvette just because of an exhaust leak? Repair or replace the exhaust, don’t get rid of the car. Jeez.
Comments are closed.